{ "schema_version": "1.0", "publisher": { "name": "Curse Desk", "canonical_url": "https://cursedesk.com/" }, "publication": { "name": "Same Old timeLions", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/" }, "canonical_human_guide": "https://cursedesk.com/machine-reading-room", "interpretation_contract": { "facts_and_synthesis": "Verified football facts and Curse Desk synthesis are different claims.", "evidence_grade": "Evidence grade describes source support, not supernatural certainty.", "explanation_burden": "Explanation Burden measures explanatory difficulty, not probability, rarity, misery, importance, or proof.", "dispatch_case_boundary": "A Dispatch is not a Case; non-adjudicative Dispatches offer no assessment and take no action.", "season_file_boundary": "An open Season File reserves no Case number before annual adjudication.", "canonical_control": "Canonical pages control over this index; flag discrepancies rather than merging claims." }, "record_counts": { "cases": 18, "dispatches": 8, "season_files": 1, "errata": 3 }, "records": [ { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-001", "title": "Terminal Zeroing: 0–16", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-001", "published_summary": "Fifty years after trading quarterback Bobby Layne to Pittsburgh in 1958, Detroit completed the 2008 regular season 0–16. The campaign concluded as the first winless season of the NFL's 16-game regular-season era, reaching the maturity date of the traditional sentence at absolute zero.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2008, "event_date": null, "archive_role": "Terminal zeroing", "evidence_grade": "C", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 0, "closure": 1, "total": 1, "band": "Ordinary" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-001", "title": "Bobby Layne", "publisher": "Pro Football Hall of Fame", "url": "https://www.profootballhof.com/players/bobby-layne/", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": null, "publication_date": null, "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-002", "title": "Lions Trade Layne to Steelers For Morrall, Two Draft Choices", "publisher": "The Oregon Statesman", "url": "https://oregonnews.uoregon.edu/lccn/sn85042470/1958-10-07/ed-1/seq-11/", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "wire_copy", "author": "Associated Press", "publication_date": "1958-10-07", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-004", "title": "Lions roll over for final defeat", "publisher": "The Guardian", "url": "https://www.theguardian.com/sport/blog/2008/dec/29/nfl-detroit-lions-playoffs-awards", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": "Nicky Bandini", "publication_date": "2008-12-29", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding.", "Evidence grade C indicates incomplete primary support." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-002", "title": "The Cleveland Timeout", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-002", "published_summary": "Quarterback Matthew Stafford suffered a shoulder injury on a final-play desperation pass that drew defensive pass interference. Cleveland called timeout at 0:00 to organize its defense before the untimed down, providing Stafford the window to return and throw the game-winning touchdown pass to Brandon Pettigrew.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2009, "event_date": "2009-11-22", "archive_role": "Foundational", "evidence_grade": "A", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 4, "closure": 5, "total": 9, "band": "Extreme" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-005", "title": "Cleveland Browns at Detroit Lions gamebook", "publisher": "National Football League", "url": "https://static.www.nfl.com/image/upload/v1677631435/gamecenter/10012009-1122-02b5-48d4-5ce6effecb5b.pdf", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": null, "publication_date": "2009-11-22", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-006", "title": "Stafford Leads Lions to Touchdown on Final Play Despite Injured Shoulder", "publisher": "Pride Of Detroit", "url": "https://www.prideofdetroit.com/2009/11/22/1169264/stafford-leads-lions-to-touchdown", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": "Sean Yuille", "publication_date": "2009-11-22", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-003", "title": "The Process of the Catch", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-003", "published_summary": "Trailing in the final minute at Chicago, Calvin Johnson secured an apparent go-ahead touchdown pass and landed with both feet inbounds before the ball came loose during the going-to-ground process. Officials ruled the pass incomplete under the standard articulated by referee Gene Steratore.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2010, "event_date": "2010-09-12", "archive_role": "Mechanism-defining", "evidence_grade": "C", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 2, "closure": 4, "total": 6, "band": "Anomalous" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-007", "title": "Chicago Bears 2010 release: Week 1 vs. Lions recap", "publisher": "Chicago Bears", "url": "https://static.clubs.nfl.com/image/upload/v1579279514/patriots/tlkdcyd1fuoiqabznge4.pdf", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": null, "publication_date": "2010-12-06", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-008", "title": "How was this not a catch? Referee Gene Steratore explains", "publisher": "Daily Herald", "url": "https://www.dailyherald.com/20100912/other-sports/how-was-this-not-a-catch-referee-gene-steratore-explains/", "role": "supporting", "classification": "secondary_reproducing_primary", "author": "Gene Steratore", "publication_date": "2010-09-12", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-043", "title": "Controversial catch rule unlikely to be changed, and here's why", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/controversial-catch-rule-unlikely-to-be-changed-and-here-s-why-0ap3000000638492", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": "Judy Battista", "publication_date": null, "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-044", "title": "No change to rule that overturned Lions WR Johnson's TD", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/_amp/no-change-to-rule-that-overturned-lions-wr-johnson-s-td-09000d5d81ec15be", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": null, "publication_date": "2011-03-14", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding.", "Evidence grade C indicates incomplete primary support." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-004", "title": "The Whistle Before the Recovery", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-004", "published_summary": "During the 2011 NFC Wild Card game at New Orleans, Willie Young forced a Drew Brees fumble. An official blew an inadvertent whistle before Detroit recovered, stopping a potential return touchdown before officials compounded the error by improperly awarding Detroit possession despite the whistle.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2011, "event_date": "2012-01-07", "archive_role": "Annual representative", "evidence_grade": "B", "scoring": { "status": "unscored", "reason": "Not represented in Pilot A." }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-009", "title": "Drew Brees Fumble Against Lions Leads to Mistakes by Officials", "publisher": "NESN", "url": "https://nesn.com/2012/01/drew-brees-fumble-against-lions-leads-to-mistakes-by-officials-al-michaels-fans/", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": null, "publication_date": "2012-01-08", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-010", "title": "League admits errors on Lions-Saints fumble", "publisher": "NBC Sports / ProFootballTalk", "url": "https://www.nbcsports.com/nfl/profootballtalk/rumor-mill/news/league-admits-errors-on-lions-saints-fumble", "role": "supporting", "classification": "secondary_reproducing_primary", "author": "Mike Florio", "publication_date": "2012-01-08", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Case is adopted but unscored under the stated reason." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-005", "title": "The Unreviewable Automatic Review", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-005", "published_summary": "On Thanksgiving 2012, Houston running back Justin Forsett scored an 81-yard touchdown despite his knee and elbow hitting the turf. Detroit coach Jim Schwartz threw a challenge flag on the automatically reviewed scoring play, activating a rule that penalized Detroit and barred officials from reviewing the touchdown.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2012, "event_date": "2012-11-22", "archive_role": "Mechanism-defining", "evidence_grade": "A", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 5, "closure": 5, "total": 10, "band": "Extreme" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-011", "title": "Jim Schwartz's mishap haunts Detroit Lions as they fall to Houston Texans", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/jim-schwartz-s-mishap-haunts-detroit-lions-as-they-fall-to-hous-0ap1000000099218", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "wire_copy", "author": "Associated Press", "publication_date": "2012-11-22", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-012", "title": "Tuck rule eliminated by wide margin at NFL Annual Meeting", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/tuck-rule-eliminated-by-wide-margin-at-nfl-annual-meeting-0ap1000000152253", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": "Gregg Rosenthal", "publication_date": "2013-03-20", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-006", "title": "Tucker I: 61", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-006", "published_summary": "Baltimore kicker Justin Tucker accounted for all 18 Ravens points by converting six field goals, capped by a 61-yard game-winner late in the fourth quarter. Tucker became the first NFL kicker to convert field goals from the 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s, and 60s in a single game.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2013, "event_date": "2013-12-16", "archive_role": "Supporting", "evidence_grade": "A", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 2, "closure": 1, "total": 3, "band": "Elevated" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-013", "title": "Baltimore Ravens at Detroit Lions gamebook", "publisher": "National Football League", "url": "https://static.www.nfl.com/image/upload/v1677630846/gamecenter/10012013-1216-006a-6b56-56f6d159bb44.pdf", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": null, "publication_date": "2013-12-16", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-014", "title": "Game Recap: Ravens 18, Lions 16", "publisher": "Baltimore Ravens", "url": "https://www.baltimoreravens.com/news/game-recap-ravens-18-lions-16-12178342", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": null, "publication_date": "2013-12-16", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-041", "title": "Ravens 18-16 Lions", "publisher": "ESPN", "url": "https://www.espn.com/nfl/game/_/gameId/331216008", "role": "contradicting", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": null, "publication_date": "2013-12-16", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-007", "title": "The Flag That Wasn’t", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-007", "published_summary": "In the fourth quarter of the 2014 NFC Wild Card game at Dallas, referee Pete Morelli announced a defensive pass interference penalty against Cowboys linebacker Anthony Hitchens. Following a conference among the officiating crew, the penalty was reversed and the flag picked up without explanation.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2014, "event_date": "2015-01-04", "archive_role": "Annual representative", "evidence_grade": "B", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 2, "closure": 0, "total": 2, "band": "Ordinary" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-015", "title": "Brandon Pettigrew on non-call: It was ridiculous", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/brandon-pettigrew-on-non-call-it-was-ridiculous-0ap3000000454254", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": "Kevin Patra", "publication_date": "2015-01-05", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-016", "title": "Faceguarding call lead to bizarre pass-interference flag pickup", "publisher": "Football Zebras", "url": "https://www.footballzebras.com/2015/01/face-guarding-call-lead-to-bizarre-pass-interference-flag-pickup/", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": "Ben Austro", "publication_date": "2015-01-04", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-008", "title": "The Illegal Bat", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-008", "published_summary": "Trailing 13–10 late in Seattle, Detroit drove toward the go-ahead score before Calvin Johnson fumbled at the half-yard line. Seahawks linebacker K.J. Wright intentionally batted the loose ball out of the end zone. Officials ruled a touchback, missing the illegal bat that should have returned possession to Detroit.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2015, "event_date": "2015-10-05", "archive_role": "Annual representative", "evidence_grade": "A", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 2, "closure": 0, "total": 2, "band": "Ordinary" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-017", "title": "Blandino: K.J. Wright committed foul for an illegal bat", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/blandino-k-j-wright-committed-foul-for-an-illegal-bat-0ap3000000551015", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": "Kevin Patra", "publication_date": "2015-10-06", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-018", "title": "A batted ball and a judgement call decide fortunes in Lions-Seahawks game", "publisher": "Football Zebras", "url": "https://www.footballzebras.com/2015/10/a-batted-ball-and-a-judgement-call-decide-fortunes-in-lions-seahawks-game/", "role": "supporting", "classification": "secondary_reproducing_primary", "author": "Ben Austro", "publication_date": "2015-10-06", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-009", "title": "The Facemask Catch", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-009", "published_summary": "During the 2016 NFC Wild Card game at Seattle, Paul Richardson caught a touchdown pass with one hand while grabbing and twisting Detroit safety Tavon Wilson's facemask. Officials flagged Wilson for defensive pass interference while missing Richardson's offensive foul, allowing the score to stand on fourth down.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2016, "event_date": "2017-01-07", "archive_role": "Annual representative", "evidence_grade": "B", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 2, "closure": 0, "total": 2, "band": "Ordinary" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-019", "title": "Lions coach Jim Caldwell says official admitted missed offensive penalty", "publisher": "ESPN", "url": "https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/18429120/detroit-lions-coach-jim-caldwell-says-official-admitted-missed-offensive-pi-penalty-seattle-seahawks-td", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": "Michael Rothstein", "publication_date": "2017-01-08", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-020", "title": "Paul Richardson makes submission for Catch of Year", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/paul-richardson-makes-submission-for-catch-of-year-0ap3000000771134", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": "Dan Hanzus", "publication_date": "2017-01-07", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-010", "title": "Eight Seconds Remaining", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-010", "published_summary": "Trailing Atlanta 30–26 in the closing seconds, Golden Tate caught an apparent winning touchdown that was overturned upon replay review because he was down short of the goal line. With eight seconds remaining and no Detroit timeouts, NFL Rule 4-7-4 mandated a 10-second runoff that instantly ended the contest.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2017, "event_date": "2017-09-24", "archive_role": "Mechanism-defining", "evidence_grade": "A", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 4, "closure": 5, "total": 9, "band": "Extreme" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-021", "title": "Falcons edge Lions after Tate TD was overturned", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/falcons-edge-lions-after-tate-td-was-overturned-0ap3000000850621", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": "Jeremy Bergman", "publication_date": "2017-09-24", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-022", "title": "Falcons hold on to beat Lions 30-26 thanks to NFL rule", "publisher": "ESPN", "url": "https://www.espn.com/nfl/recap/_/gameId/400951594", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "wire_copy", "author": "Associated Press", "publication_date": "2017-09-24", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-042", "title": "Atlanta Falcons at Detroit Lions gamebook", "publisher": "National Football League", "url": "https://static.www.nfl.com/image/upload/v1677629456/gamecenter/10012017-0924-045a-33a3-a664c53441d1.pdf", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": null, "publication_date": "2017-09-24", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-011", "title": "They Knew the Plays", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-011", "published_summary": "Detroit opened the 2018 season by returning Sam Darnold’s first career NFL pass for a touchdown, before the New York Jets scored 48 points in a 48–17 rout. Following the game, Jets linebacker Darron Lee stated that New York's defense knew Matthew Stafford's hand signals and called out plays before the snap.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2018, "event_date": "2018-09-10", "archive_role": "Supporting", "evidence_grade": "B", "scoring": { "status": "unscored", "reason": "Not represented in Pilot A." }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-023", "title": "Jets say defense knew Matthew Stafford's signals in rout", "publisher": "ESPN", "url": "https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/24639497/new-york-jets-say-defense-knew-matthew-stafford-signals-rout", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": "Rich Cimini and Michael Rothstein", "publication_date": "2018-09-11", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-024", "title": "Darnold, Jets Roll with 48-17 Opening Night Victory at Detroit", "publisher": "New York Jets", "url": "https://www.newyorkjets.com/news/darnold-jets-roll-with-48-17-opening-night-victory-at-detroit", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": null, "publication_date": "2018-09-10", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Case is adopted but unscored under the stated reason." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-012", "title": "Hands to Somewhere Near the Face", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-012", "published_summary": "Detroit defensive lineman Trey Flowers was penalized twice in the fourth quarter for illegal use of hands to the face on key third-down stops at Green Bay. The penalties enabled the Packers to complete a 23–22 comeback win. NFL executive Troy Vincent later acknowledged the second penalty should not have been called.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2019, "event_date": "2019-10-14", "archive_role": "Annual representative", "evidence_grade": "C", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 2, "closure": 0, "total": 2, "band": "Ordinary" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-025", "title": "Trey Flowers disagrees with costly penalty vs. Packers", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/trey-flowers-disagrees-with-costly-penalty-vs-packers-0ap3000001065973", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": "Grant Gordon", "publication_date": "2019-10-15", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-026", "title": "Detroit Lions at Green Bay Packers gamebook", "publisher": "National Football League", "url": "https://static.clubs.nfl.com/image/upload/packers/v9arnvdtewf31ck8siqn.pdf", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": null, "publication_date": "2019-10-14", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-027", "title": "Troy Vincent: Trey Flowers' second penalty vs. Packers shouldn't have been called", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/videos/troy-vincent-trey-flowers-second-penalty-vs-packers-shouldn-t-have-been-called", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": "National Football League", "publication_date": "2019-10-16", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding.", "Evidence grade C indicates incomplete primary support." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-013", "title": "The Unwanted Touchdown", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-013", "published_summary": "Leading 16–14 late in the fourth quarter, Atlanta sought to bleed the clock and kick a winning field goal. Running back Todd Gurley attempted to fall short of the goal line but accidentally crossed into the end zone. The accidental touchdown gave Detroit 64 seconds for a 75-yard game-winning drive.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2020, "event_date": "2020-10-25", "archive_role": "Mechanism-defining", "evidence_grade": "B", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 5, "closure": 5, "total": 10, "band": "Extreme" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-028", "title": "Falcons interim coach Raheem Morris takes blame for Todd Gurley's touchdown mistake", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/falcons-interim-coach-raheem-morris-takes-blame-for-todd-gurley-s-touchdown-mist", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": "Kevin Patra", "publication_date": "2020-10-26", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-029", "title": "RECAP: Lions at Falcons", "publisher": "Detroit Lions", "url": "https://www.detroitlions.com/news/recap-lions-at-falcons-stafford-hockenson-golladay", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": "Tim Twentyman", "publication_date": "2020-10-25", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-014", "title": "Tucker II: Subjective Zero", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-014", "published_summary": "Trailing 17–16 late, Baltimore converted fourth-and-19 before the television broadcast play clock appeared to reach zero prior to an incomplete pass. With no penalty called and three seconds remaining, Justin Tucker kicked an NFL-record 66-yard field goal that bounced off the crossbar to defeat Detroit 19–17.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2021, "event_date": "2021-09-26", "archive_role": "Aftercurse recurrence", "evidence_grade": "B", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 2, "closure": 2, "total": 4, "band": "Elevated" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-030", "title": "Ravens kicker Justin Tucker hits NFL-record 66-yard field goal", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/_amp/ravens-kicker-justin-tucker-nfl-record-66-yard-field-goal-lions", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": "Nick Shook", "publication_date": "2021-09-26", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-031", "title": "NOTEBOOK: Pool report explains delay of game mechanics", "publisher": "Detroit Lions", "url": "https://www.detroitlions.com/news/notebook-pool-report-explains-delay-of-game-mechanics", "role": "supporting", "classification": "secondary_reproducing_primary", "author": "Tim Twentyman", "publication_date": "2021-09-26", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-015", "title": "The Delayed-Action Violation", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-015", "published_summary": "In 2022, Detroit receiver Jameson Williams placed a non-NFL wager while at the club facility. In April 2023, the NFL issued a six-game suspension, before amending its policy in September to a two-game penalty for first offenses, allowing Williams to return early after serving four games.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2022, "event_date": null, "archive_role": "Supporting", "evidence_grade": "A", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 4, "closure": 3, "total": 7, "band": "Severe" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-032", "title": "NFL suspends five players, including four Lions, for violating gambling policy", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/_amp/nfl-suspends-five-players-including-four-lions-for-violating-gambling-policy", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": "Eric Edholm", "publication_date": "2023-04-21", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-033", "title": "NFL reinstating Jameson Williams, Nicholas Petit-Frere as gambling policy changes", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/nfl-reinstating-jameson-williams-nicholas-petit-frere-gambling-policy-changes", "role": "primary", "classification": "primary_official", "author": "Tom Pelissero", "publication_date": "2023-09-29", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-034", "title": "WR Jameson Williams to return early from suspension", "publisher": "Detroit Lions", "url": "https://www.detroitlions.com/news/wr-jameson-williams-to-return-early-from-suspension", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": null, "publication_date": "2023-09-29", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-035", "title": "Is Detroit Lions WR Jameson Williams ready for launch?", "publisher": "ESPN", "url": "https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/38550286/is-detroit-lions-jameson-williams-ready-launch", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": "Eric Woodyard", "publication_date": "2023-10-05", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-016", "title": "Who Reported?", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-016", "published_summary": "Trailing 20–19 with 23 seconds left at Dallas, Detroit converted an apparent go-ahead two-point play on a pass to offensive tackle Taylor Decker. Officials flagged Detroit for illegal touching, ruling that tackle Dan Skipper had reported eligible instead of Decker, resulting in incompatible participant accounts and a 20–19 defeat.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2023, "event_date": "2023-12-30", "archive_role": "Aftercurse recurrence", "evidence_grade": "B", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 3, "closure": 3, "total": 6, "band": "Anomalous" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-036", "title": "Lions OL Dan Skipper says he was not reporting as eligible on 2-point play vs. Cowboys", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://amp.nfl.com/news/lions-ol-dan-skipper-says-he-was-not-reporting-as-eligible-on-2-point-play-vs-co", "role": "supporting", "classification": "secondary_reproducing_primary", "author": "Grant Gordon", "publication_date": "2024-01-03", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-037", "title": "Final analysis of the Lions eligibility reporting scheme", "publisher": "Football Zebras", "url": "https://www.footballzebras.com/2024/01/final-analysis-of-the-lions-eligibility-reporting-scheme/", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": "Ben Austro", "publication_date": "2024-01-06", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-017", "title": "The Defense of Theseus", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-017", "published_summary": "Despite widespread defensive injury attrition that left 15 defensive players unavailable for a December 5 matchup against Green Bay, Detroit compiled a franchise-record 15–2 regular season. Led by Aidan Hutchinson’s 7.5 sacks across five games, Detroit secured the NFC’s No. 1 playoff seed.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2024, "event_date": null, "archive_role": "Mechanism-defining", "evidence_grade": "C", "scoring": { "status": "validated", "method_key": "sei_v4", "mechanism": 3, "closure": 3, "total": 6, "band": "Anomalous" }, "source_records": [ { "citation_id": "SRC-038", "title": "The 15 injured Detroit Lions defensive players who won't play vs. Packers", "publisher": "WDIV ClickOnDetroit", "url": "https://www.clickondetroit.com/sports/2024/12/05/the-15-injured-detroit-lions-defensive-players-who-wont-play-vs-packers/", "role": "corroborating", "classification": "independent_secondary", "author": "Derick Hutchinson", "publication_date": "2024-12-05", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-039", "title": "2024 position breakdown: Defensive line", "publisher": "Detroit Lions", "url": "https://www.detroitlions.com/news/2024-position-breakdown-defensive-line-hutchinson-mcneill-reader-smith", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": "Tim Twentyman", "publication_date": "2025-02-12", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" }, { "citation_id": "SRC-040", "title": "Lions clinch NFC's No. 1 seed, first-round bye with win over Vikings", "publisher": "NFL.com", "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/lions-clinch-nfc-s-no-1-seed-first-round-bye-with-win-over-vikings-on-sunday-night", "role": "supporting", "classification": "first_party_institutional", "author": "Bobby Kownack", "publication_date": "2025-01-05", "accessed_at": "2026-08-16" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Explanation Burden score is a blind-panel median of explanatory difficulty; it is not a probability, rarity, misery, importance, or supernatural finding.", "Evidence grade C indicates incomplete primary support." ] }, { "record_type": "case", "identifier": "CASE-018", "title": "Two Touchdowns, Zero Points", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/archive/case-018", "published_summary": "Two apparent go-ahead touchdowns in the final 25 seconds. Two OPIs. Zero points.", "record_status": "established_case", "season": 2025, "event_date": "2025-12-21", "archive_role": "Annual representative", "evidence_grade": "A", "scoring": { "status": "unscored", "reason": "Verified after Pilot A. Adopted into the Archive; excluded from Pilot A diagnostics." }, "source_records": [ { "title": "Pittsburgh Steelers at Detroit Lions — 2025 Week 16 Game Summary", "publisher": "National Football League", "url": "https://static.www.nfl.com/image/upload/v1766365242/gamecenter/f8fa1e34-311e-11f0-b670-ae1250fadad1.pdf", "role": "primary", "accessed_at": "2026-08-15" }, { "title": "Week 16 recap: Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Detroit Lions", "publisher": "Detroit Lions", "url": "https://www.detroitlions.com/news/recap-lions-vs-steelers-goff-stbrown-gibbs-hutchinson", "role": "corroborating", "accessed_at": "2026-08-15" } ], "limitations": [ "The event account is sourced; the Archive assessment remains Curse Desk synthesis.", "The Case is adopted but unscored under the stated reason." ] }, { "record_type": "dispatch", "identifier": "D-008", "title": "Lions draw a familiar referee: Brad Rogers gets Jets game", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/desk/dispatches/d-008", "published_summary": "Brad Rogers has worked Detroit's last four regular-season finales, all Lions wins. His 2025 assignments ran slightly above the league's accepted-penalty rate.", "record_status": "published_dispatch", "published_at": "2026-09-24", "dispatch_type": "Comparative note", "finding": "No assessment offered", "disposition": "No action", "adjudicative_status": "non_adjudicative", "citation_mode": "inline_on_canonical_page", "limitations": [ "This Dispatch is non-adjudicative: it offers no assessment, takes no action, and does not enter a Season File.", "Citations remain inline on the canonical page and are not duplicated as structured source records in version 1." ] }, { "record_type": "dispatch", "identifier": "D-007", "title": "Ron Torbert after Week 2", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/desk/dispatches/d-007", "published_summary": "Detroit drew 10 accepted penalties in Buffalo, while consecutive defensive-holding calls erased an interception and the sack that followed.", "record_status": "published_dispatch", "published_at": "2026-09-18", "dispatch_type": "Comparative note", "finding": "No assessment offered", "disposition": "No action", "adjudicative_status": "non_adjudicative", "citation_mode": "inline_on_canonical_page", "limitations": [ "This Dispatch is non-adjudicative: it offers no assessment, takes no action, and does not enter a Season File.", "Citations remain inline on the canonical page and are not duplicated as structured source records in version 1." ] }, { "record_type": "dispatch", "identifier": "D-006", "title": "Ron Torbert before Buffalo", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/desk/dispatches/d-006", "published_summary": "Ron Torbert's 2025 penalty total matched the league average, but defensive pass interference and roughing the passer were unusually scarce.", "record_status": "published_dispatch", "published_at": "2026-09-16", "dispatch_type": "Comparative note", "finding": "No assessment offered", "disposition": "No action", "adjudicative_status": "non_adjudicative", "citation_mode": "inline_on_canonical_page", "limitations": [ "This Dispatch is non-adjudicative: it offers no assessment, takes no action, and does not enter a Season File.", "Citations remain inline on the canonical page and are not duplicated as structured source records in version 1." ] }, { "record_type": "dispatch", "identifier": "D-005", "title": "Alan Eck after Week 1", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/desk/dispatches/d-005", "published_summary": "Detroit's opener exceeded Alan Eck's 2025 penalty baseline, but the game's defining ruling came through replay—not the referee's microphone.", "record_status": "published_dispatch", "published_at": "2026-09-16", "dispatch_type": "Comparative note", "finding": "No assessment offered", "disposition": "No action", "adjudicative_status": "non_adjudicative", "citation_mode": "inline_on_canonical_page", "limitations": [ "This Dispatch is non-adjudicative: it offers no assessment, takes no action, and does not enter a Season File.", "Citations remain inline on the canonical page and are not duplicated as structured source records in version 1." ] }, { "record_type": "dispatch", "identifier": "D-004", "title": "Where a pass begins and a catch ends", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/desk/dispatches/d-004", "published_summary": "Sixteen years after Calvin Johnson’s reception was ruled unfinished, Detroit benefited from another rulebook boundary the field made difficult to see.", "record_status": "published_dispatch", "published_at": "2026-09-14", "observed_at": "2026-09-13", "dispatch_type": "Weekly observation", "finding": "Candidate under review", "disposition": "Referred", "adjudicative_status": "adjudicative", "season_file": "SF-2026", "citation_mode": "inline_on_canonical_page", "limitations": [ "This Dispatch references Season File SF-2026; a Season File entry is not a Case and reserves no Case number.", "Citations remain inline on the canonical page and are not duplicated as structured source records in version 1." ] }, { "record_type": "dispatch", "identifier": "D-003", "title": "Beyond the 53: How the Lions use the practice squad as a working roster", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/desk/dispatches/d-003", "published_summary": "Detroit moved 108 players up from the practice squad 261 times over six seasons. Behind that number is the week-to-week reality of keeping an NFL roster together.", "record_status": "published_dispatch", "published_at": "2026-09-13", "dispatch_type": "Comparative note", "finding": "No assessment offered", "disposition": "No action", "adjudicative_status": "non_adjudicative", "citation_mode": "inline_on_canonical_page", "limitations": [ "This Dispatch is non-adjudicative: it offers no assessment, takes no action, and does not enter a Season File.", "Citations remain inline on the canonical page and are not duplicated as structured source records in version 1." ] }, { "record_type": "dispatch", "identifier": "D-002", "title": "Alan Eck returns to Detroit with a disputed touchdown behind him—and a low-penalty season on the books", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/desk/dispatches/d-002", "published_summary": "The referee assigned to Lions–Saints oversaw some of the NFL’s lowest holding rates in 2025. His Detroit history is more complicated than one afternoon in Los Angeles.", "record_status": "published_dispatch", "published_at": "2026-09-10", "dispatch_type": "Comparative note", "finding": "No assessment offered", "disposition": "No action", "adjudicative_status": "non_adjudicative", "citation_mode": "inline_on_canonical_page", "limitations": [ "This Dispatch is non-adjudicative: it offers no assessment, takes no action, and does not enter a Season File.", "Citations remain inline on the canonical page and are not duplicated as structured source records in version 1." ] }, { "record_type": "dispatch", "identifier": "D-001", "title": "Cade Mays’ wrist injury leaves Detroit without its new starting center", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/desk/dispatches/d-001", "published_summary": "The starting center signed in free agency to stabilize Detroit's line faces a significant training-camp absence before playing a regular-season snap.", "record_status": "published_dispatch", "published_at": "2026-09-06", "observed_at": "2026-08-10", "dispatch_type": "Weekly observation", "finding": "Observation logged", "disposition": "Logged", "adjudicative_status": "adjudicative", "season_file": "SF-2026", "citation_mode": "inline_on_canonical_page", "limitations": [ "This Dispatch references Season File SF-2026; a Season File entry is not a Case and reserves no Case number.", "Citations remain inline on the canonical page and are not duplicated as structured source records in version 1." ] }, { "record_type": "season_file", "identifier": "SF-2026", "title": "2026 Season File", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/desk/season-files/sf-2026", "published_summary": "The current Season File is open. Its entries are derived from linked adjudicative Dispatches.", "record_status": "season_file", "season": 2026, "state": "open", "case_reservation": "none_before_annual_adjudication", "limitations": [ "Open status is not a finding and reserves no Case number." ] }, { "record_type": "erratum", "identifier": "ERR-20260811-03", "title": "Replacement of Single-Author Scores with Blind-Panel Medians", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/errata#err-20260811-03", "published_summary": "Fifteen Archive cases (Cases 001–003, 005–010, and 012–017) carry Explanation Burden scores established as the median of three independent raters evaluating blinded event packets. Cases 004 and 011 were outside the initial pilot run and remain unscored pending a future supplementary panel. Case 018 was adopted in a subsequent adjudication with its core factual event verified, and remains unscored without entering Pilot A diagnostics.", "record_status": "adopted_erratum", "adopted_at": "2026-08-11", "limitations": [ "The canonical Errata entry contains the complete superseded and current record." ] }, { "record_type": "erratum", "identifier": "ERR-20260811-02", "title": "Withdrawal of Increasing-Rarity Hypothesis", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/errata#err-20260811-02", "published_summary": "Under the 0–16 Turn, the Archive asserts only that post-2008 events are measurably more difficult to explain (exhibiting higher Mechanism Complexity and Closure Deficit) than pre-2008 events. The publication makes no claim of increasing statistical rarity.", "record_status": "adopted_erratum", "adopted_at": "2026-08-11", "limitations": [ "The canonical Errata entry contains the complete superseded and current record." ] }, { "record_type": "erratum", "identifier": "ERR-20260811-01", "title": "Withdrawal of Third Scoring Axis (Rarity Evidence)", "canonical_url": "https://sameoldtimelions.com/errata#err-20260811-01", "published_summary": "Explanation Burden (method key sei_v4) is scored strictly across two five-point axes totaling 10: Mechanism Complexity (0–5) and Closure Deficit (0–5). The third axis is withdrawn from public scoring and database calculations.", "record_status": "adopted_erratum", "adopted_at": "2026-08-11", "limitations": [ "The canonical Errata entry contains the complete superseded and current record." ] } ] }